The Best Mattresses of 2018
Your guide to buying a mattress online
Buying a mattress online can be complicated. With so many choices, it's tough to scan reviews and know which is right for you. So we created this buying guide to make your life a little easier. Below, we feature our choices for the best mattresses in Australia through popular categories: sleeping position, firmness, material, and value.
If you're looking for a mattress in a box that meets your sleeping habits, this guide will help. It lets you get a feel for each design (without actually laying on it). Our team works hard to combine customer reviews, expert opinions, and company information into mattress descriptions. We find the strengths and weaknesses of every brand, cutting through gimmicks to bring you clear information. While we do partner with mattress brands, we work hard to mitigate bias and bring you informed data.
Here are Australia's best mattresses in a box
Best for Side Sleepers
Our picks — Sommuto and Sleep Republic
While side sleeping is one of most popular positions, it can be hard on the body. All of your weight is put on shoulders, torso, and hips. This pressure can cause problems without the right mattress. Sleepers can wake up with sore backs or stiff necks. The worst is when an arm falls asleep during the night. To avoid these problems, you should look for a mattress that combines pressure relief and support with the right sinking softness.
Overall, we believe the best mattress for side sleepers is one with a balanced firmness. A not too hard, not too soft feel gives sleepers cushion while keeping the shoulders, hips, neck, and knees aligned. If a mattress is too squishy, it cannot evenly support each body part. If it's too firm, it causes soreness. That's why we looked for a medium firmness that allows the body to sink, but also gives enough support for body-shaping contour.
The Sommuto Mattress
All things considered, we think side sleepers will love the Sommuto mattress. Manufactured and sold exclusively in Australia, this mattress is made to hit the "sweet spot." It's constructed of high-quality foam and fabric, and excludes any foreign materials. While the Sommuto costs more than the average foam mattress, it's worth the price if you're searching for a quality, durable design. If you flip from side to side every night, this mattress may be perfect for you.
Besides being an Australian-made mattress, there are plenty of reasons to love the Sommuto. It combines gel-infused memory foam, comfort foam, and a high-density support foam for a balanced feel. The memory foam is great for pressure relief and the gel helps distribute heat. Underneath this layer is the Sommuto's secret—a contouring comfort foam. This layer provides support while flexing to your body's curves. A perfect feel for side sleepers. Another plus is the breathable knit cover. Made from Tempright fabric, it's ideal for seasonal climates and sleepers who overheat.
The Sleep Republic Mattress
The Sleep Republic mattress is another great option suitable for side sleepers. Priced below the Sommuto, it has different features but achieves a similar feel. It's a hybrid design using foam and pocket springs for a soft, snug firmness. A luxurious top comfort layer gives instant pressure relief, while the strong spring base offers lasting support.
Best for Stomach Sleepers
Our pick — Luxi
There's a lot of talk about whether sleeping on your stomach is bad for your health. Some say this position can cause strain on your back. One tip to reduce back pain is to put a pillow under your pelvis and abdomen. While we're not medical experts, we know there are plenty of people who prefer this sleeping position. If you're one of them, finding the right mattress can make a major difference in sleep quality.
An ideal mattress for stomach sleepers is plush enough to take pressure off of your chest, knees, and hips. At the same time, it needs to keep your neck and spine aligned (or else you may wake up with back pain). Keep in mind, it's also key to have a pillow that keeps your head even. Thin pillows work great for stomach sleepers since they prevent your head from resting at uneven angles. It's also a good pillow to put under your pelvis. While it's easy to switch out pillows, choosing a mattress is more complicated. That's why we pulled data from real stomach sleepers to help choose an excellent mattress.
The Luxi Mattress
All things considered, we believe the best mattress for stomach sleepers is the Luxi. While this position will find the Luxi most comfortable, people who constantly switch positions will also enjoy this adjustable design. With three possible firmness levels, it's one of the most customisable mattress you can buy online. You can change out three foam layers for a medium, medium-firm, or firm feel. Each foam is different—latex, memory foam, and poly foam—to give the ultimate custom feel. Plus, each side can be individually adjusted. A perfect feature for partners. Because no one should compromise on a good night's sleep.
Due to the adjustable firmness levels, the Luxi works for a variety of sleeping positions. (Hint: scroll down to see the other category Luxi won). However, the special memory foam layer makes it ideal for stomach sleepers. This layer is unique to Luxi and lets the foam compress under light weight. For stomach sleepers, that means less pressure on your knees and chest but enough support for your back and neck.
Another reason customers love this mattress is the long trial period. While most companies give 100 days, Luxi lets you test their design for 180 days. You have plenty of time to find your favourite firmness setting and settle into a final decision. Switching layers is simple too, since the mattress cover can easily be unzipped to swap foams and sides.
Best for Bad Backs
Our pick — Ergoflex
Waking up with a sore back can throw off your entire day. It's no surprise back pain is one of the most common sleeping complaints. On the other hand, it's one of the easiest issues to fix with the right mattress. Although we're not qualified to offer health advice, we found many sleepers had reduced back pain with a supportive, firm mattress. We dove into this idea, and researched which mattress is best for people with bad backs. An ideal design holds the neck, spine, and hips in line, while contouring to support the lower back.
Since most lumbar spine issues are caused by muscle strain, it's helpful to have a mattress that supports your body. If a mattress is too firm, there will be excessive pressure on your joints and muscles. If it's too soft, your spine drops out of line. This can lead to stressed muscles, nerves, and joints. The best mattress for back pain lets you to relax into the top layer, while the bottom layers provide support and deep compression relief. Depending on the person, this can be a medium-firm to firm design. Weight, age, injury, and sleeping position also factor into your ideal firmness.
The Ergoflex Mattress
With that in mind, we think the best mattress for bad backs is the Ergoflex. This memory foam mattress offers orthopaedic pressure relief and uses hospital-grade materials. As you lie down, it slowly contours to support all the right places. Memory foam excels at stabilising joints and allowing the right areas to sink. One customer enjoyed how the mattress "moulds to your body." The Ergoflex is a good choice if you're searching for a mattress that can help alleviate back pain, has a firmer feel, and uses high-quality materials.
Other than helping relieve back pain, the Ergoflex has a unique construction to keep sleepers cool. Memory foam is known for retaining heat. But this mattress uses open-cell foam and a Cool Sleep Airflow layer to pull warmth away from sleepers. The mattress cover also contributes to a cool sleep. Made of Tencel® fabric, it's a naturally soft, breathable fabric. This material is derived from plant cells and is hypoallergenic. Underneath the top layer is a micro-fine fabric that encases and protects the foam layers from dust mites. All of these features create a quality mattress that competes with top memory foam brands. Plus, the Ergoflex is an incredible value, and you can test it at home for 30 days to see if it eases your back pain.
Best for Freestyle Sleepers
Our pick — Sleeping Duck
If you switch from back to side to stomach, you're a freestyle sleeper. These sleepers usually start in a favourite position but end up changing positions throughout the night. Moving around can be tough on your body, as different positions are most comfortable with specific firmness levels. Back sleepers enjoy a firmer feel than stomach sleepers, who need a plush top to prevent uncomfortable pressure. Side sleepers usually prefer a medium-firm mattress that lets the body melt without throwing the back and hips out of line. Finding the right balance between these three positions was tough, but the rankings and customer reviews helped us choose a mattress that fits freestyle sleepers.
To figure out which mattress was best for this combination, we focused on finding an adaptable design. Freestyle sleepers tend to fall into two categories: restless sleepers and those who have no true position preference. For some restless sleepers, finding the best mattress may improve sleep. This is also true for people without a position preference. Having a mattress that adapts to movement means you won't wake up from an awkward transition.
The Sleeping Duck Mattress
Overall, we believe a great mattress for freestyle sleepers is the Sleeping Duck. A customisable hybrid design, this mattress uses foam and springs for a supportive, bouncy feel. Customers can choose between two firmness levels—medium or firm—and then swap foam layers for a softer or firmer feel. If the mattress needs more cushion, you can request a softer layer from Sleeping Duck. The same goes for a firmer feel. Sleepers who have a hard time finding a mattress that fits just right should consider this adaptable design.
Due to the personalised firmness feature, the Sleeping Duck is great for numerous sleeping positions. Side sleepers enjoy the strong spring support and cushioned top layer. Back sleepers can opt for a firmer top layer that keeps their spines aligned. And stomach sleepers love how the gel-infused memory foam layer relieves pressure on sensitive parts. No matter the position you're in, you'll also love the natural bounce from the latex layer. This material rebounds your movement, so you're never stuck in one spot.
Underneath the foam and latex layers is a pocket spring base. Constructed of hundreds of individually-wrapped springs, this layer provides a majority of the support. This support is necessary for every sleeping position. Plus, each spring reacts to your movement separately, which means less motion transfer and more contour. The springs are also thicker towards the edges so you'll be comfortable no matter how you move.
Best Soft Mattress
Our picks — Luxi
Finding the perfect firmness is a struggle for many sleepers. There's never enough time in mattress showrooms to get a real feel. Also, your pick may not be right for a partner. To help, we used real customer reviews and our rankings to find sleepers' favourite soft mattress. This firmness level is not popular, as many companies create medium-firm and firm designs. However, several brands allow you to decrease the firmness by switching layers or flipping the mattress.
When picking a soft mattress, it's important to look for a cushioned, yet supportive, design. A mattress that is too soft can develop dips. This can cause soreness if your back and neck is out of line. On the other hand, many mattresses are too firm. They can lead to restless sleep and aching knees or hips. That's why stomach sleepers prefer a mattress that feels instantly plush, but has support in all the right places.
The Luxi Mattress
Overall, we believe the best soft mattress is the Luxi. Made of four foam layers, its unique construction lets you switch layers to change the firmness. Whether you're a solo sleeper or snooze with a partner, you can adjust it to fit a variety of sleeping styles. If you struggle to find a plush mattress, this custom design is for you.
Other than the feel, there are many reasons why we chose the Luxi. Not only can you customise the base to medium, medium-firm, or firm feel, you can also adjust the sides individually. Partners can customise their firmness level without affecting the other. The mattress also comes with a unique memory foam layer that compresses under light weight and contours to your shape. While supportive, memory foam can be too firm for lighter stomach sleepers. Luxi created a new type of memory foam that retains the support but has a plush feel.
The best part? You can try it at home for 180 days. This extra-generous trial period gives you time to adjust. If you have any questions about rearranging the Luxi, the customer service team is known for helpful answers. Even if the mattress doesn't work you for, you can return it for a full refund during the trial period. But we have a feeling you'll never want to give it back.
Best Medium Mattress
Our picks — Hugo and Sleep Republic
A majority of sleepers are most comfortable on a mattress with medium firmness. This is why many online mattresses brands choose a medium to medium-firm rating. Since firmness is largely subjective, a medium feel varies for all brands. Material also plays a part in firmness. A medium latex mattress will always feel different than a medium memory foam design. This was essential to remember as we looked for the perfect medium mattress.
Choosing the best medium firmness comes down to balance. The mattress had to be "not too soft, and not too firm." While many companies aim for this feel, it's difficult to get right. The design should hug the body, but keep the spine properly curved. Sleepers don't want to feel like they're floating on top of the mattress, but they also don't want to sink so much that they can't move around. Our mattress pick is soft with a slight bounce, so sleepers get a balanced medium feel.
The Hugo Mattress
Considering these factors, our pick for the best medium mattress is Hugo. A memory foam design, this mattress holds sleepers in all the right ways. It combines four foam layers instead of the standard three, and uses a unique memory foam material. This foam is what helps set it apart. Many customers said they tried a traditional memory foam design, but woke up with sore limbs from too much support. Hugo is different because its comfort layer lets sleepers sink and relax, while the underlying memory and base foam provides deep compression support.
Another feature that makes Hugo a great medium mattress are the latex and transitional foam layers. Unlike most memory foam mattresses, Hugo puts the latex layer on top. This is better for air circulation, bounce, and immediate comfort. A common complaint of memory foam is the firm feeling, but sleepers lie on the responsive latex before the memory foam. While sleepers are instantly comfortable, the memory foam slowly relaxes to give contour and pressure relief. To top things off, Hugo sources many of its materials in Australia and offers free shipping across the country.
The Sleep Republic Mattress
We also believe the Sleep Republic mattress is another great medium mattress. Made of foam layers and pocket springs, this hybrid is designed to fit the average sleeper. The foam comfort layer is snug, but is balanced out by the supportive spring base. These springs target your head and shoulders, torso, hips, knees, and feet with a unique five zone design. Hybrid designs like the Sleep Republic are gaining popularity, largely for their medium feel, lower price tags, and durable construction.
Best Firm Mattress
Our pick — Onebed
Notorious for helping relieve lower back pain, firm mattresses typically range from a medium-firm to firm feel. Memory foam is commonly used in these designs, since it's less responsive and provides shaping support. However, a firm foam can cause limbs to fall asleep or make you feel like you're floating.
When choosing a firm mattress, know there's a difference between firm feel and firm support. You should look for a mattress with firm support and a comfortable feel. Oftentimes, people believe a high firmness level is better for lower back pain, but it's possible to get a mattress that is too hard. While a supportive design can help alleviate back issues, it also should let your body relax without excessive pressure.
Typically, back and side sleepers are happiest with a firm mattress. These positions require less cushion and more deep compression support than stomach sleepers. That's why our firm mattress choice has a springy top and supportive middle. Sleepers settle into the first layer, but get body-shaping contour from the dense memory foam underneath. Overall, this mattress is best for sleepers who have found other foam mattresses too soft, or for heavier sleepers who need extra support.
The Onebed Mattress
If you fit the above characteristics, you'll likely get a great night's sleep on Onebed—our pick for the best firm mattress. Unlike most firm memory foam designs, it also uses latex to distribute pressure and give a slight bounce. As you lie down, the latex rebounds weight to keep your spine, shoulders, and hips in line. By putting the latex on top of the memory foam, it gives the mattress more cushion.
Another customer-favourite feature of Onebed is the cool surface. Since memory foam holds heat, many firm mattresses tend to sleep hot. The Onebed's design uses latex as a top layer to prevent this issue. Although few customers complained of heat issues, some did say it was too firm. However, the Onebed offers a generous 125-day trial period so you have ample time to adjust. If you do decide the mattress is right for you, you'll also receive the company's 15-year warranty.
A value mattress doesn't have to be low quality. In fact, many mattress brands you can buy online are durable and made with excellent materials. These brands have taken out the middlemen, so you don't have to pay outrageous prices.
To help you get the most for your money, we looked for mattresses that strip down the luxuries. Usually, the most expensive mattresses you can buy online include high-end materials, such as cashmere or hospital-grade foam. We wanted to find a mattress that was well-constructed yet unassuming. By adding only what sleepers really need, a valuable mattress brand can provide a solid sleep without an outrageous price tag. While many online mattresses are less expensive than their counterparts sold in stores, there's still a significant difference between the most and least expensive designs.
The Greywing Mattress
Ultimately, we believe the best value mattress is the Greywing. Sleepers looking for a mattress that's good for their wallets and their sleep should consider this design. With a medium-firm feel, the Greywing is ideal for side and freestyle sleepers who enjoy supportive memory foam but want to stay cool as they snooze. It's made entirely in Australia, by Australians. Every process, from engineering to foam pouring, is done in Melbourne. This is a reason why the mattress fits Aussie sleepers. Greywing's open-cell memory foam is made to keep you cool in the summer, yet warm and supported in the winter. It also features a breathable, woven cover to increase air flow.
Overall, the Greywing is right for sleepers who enjoy the feel of memory foam but need a better value than expensive high-end designs. Although it's new to the online mattress market, it already has dozens of five-star reviews. Plus, it's two to three time less expensive than the well-known mattress brands in stores. Don't be worried that the company is new—customers rave about the excellent customer service and simple return policy. You can try the Greywing at home for 100 days, and it ships free across Australia.
The Eva Mattress
Another great value mattress is the Eva. New to the mattress market, it's one of the best value hybrids available today. It's a micro-spring/foam design with bounce and body-shaping contour. This allows customers to try a foam design without losing the support of springs. However, Eva's springs are different than a traditional innerspring mattress. The mini coils act independently to lift and shape to your body. This combination of foam and springs give it a medium-firm feel, which is good for side and back sleepers. Thicker than many of its online competitors, the Eva also offers extra cushion and support.
Best Memory Foam Mattress
Our picks — Ergoflex and Sleeping Duck
Memory foam has revolutionised the mattress industry. This supportive, contouring material is a staple in many online mattress designs. There are different types of memory foams, from viscoelastic to gel-infused blends. With countless options, it's confusing to choose which memory foam mattress suits you best. Below, we look at what makes a great memory foam pick. Then, we share our choice and explain why customers love it.
It takes more than one layer of foam to make a balanced memory foam mattress. This material can be too firm for a lot of sleepers. A great mattress is medium-firm and lets you melt into the layers. It shouldn't feel incredibly soft on first contact, but it should quickly relax under weight. Often, mattress brands add a comfort layer of bouncy latex or plush poly foam. There also must be a strong support layer for increased durability and deep compression relief.
Our choice of memory foam mattress considers both construction and feel. Unlike online competitors, this company has been around for over a decade. It's a surprisingly affordable design, given the quality materials and industry knowledge. Most importantly, the mattress' memory foam hugs sleepers and helps relieve pressure. It offers great support, and is ideal for people struggling with soreness or joint pain. If you're ready to try memory foam, or have been searching for an alternative to high-end models, we think you'll be happy with this pick.
The Ergoflex Mattress
All in all, our choice for the best memory foam mattress is the Ergoflex. On top of offering body-shaping contour, this mattress provides orthopaedic-friendly pressure relief. It's made with hospital-grade materials that cradle and support sleepers. The open-cell memory foam also disperses heat for cooler summer sleep. Plus, the natural Tencel fiber cover improves airflow. Its dense foam layers are supportive, yet soft enough to help alleviate joint, hip, and back pain. With over a decade of sleep experience, the Ergoflex reflects innovation and value.
The Sleeping Duck
While the Ergoflex is right for some, the Sleeping Duck is also a good memory foam mattress. It's an adjustable hybrid mattress that combines memory foam and pocket springs. To change the firmness, you can swap foam layers for a personalised feel. If your mattress doesn't feel right, the customer support team sends softer or firmer layers (depending on your preference). However, the Sleeping Duck is more expensive than the Ergoflex. This is likely due to the custom firmness feature and high-quality materials. If you're a selective sleeper, the price may be worth the adjustment capabilities.
Best Latex Mattress
Latex mattresses have become increasingly popular over the years, as sleepers search for alternatives to spring and memory foam. Naturally bouncy, responsive, cooling, and breathable, latex mattresses are relatively easy to produce. They are also considered more environmentally-friendly, as natural latex is readily available. Authentic latex foam is made by reducing liquid latex from a rubber tree to a condensed state. Then, the latex is mixed with air to create a responsive foam with spring and support.
A quality latex mattress uses this type of foam. Although manufactured and blended latex exists, the authentic product is known to be healthier. Synthetic latex often releases an off-gassing smell, although it does disappear after a few days. Both materials provide a similar feel, but 100% latex can be much more expensive. Mattresses made from all-natural latex often cost several thousand dollars, while latex blends are priced around $1,000. No matter the material, all latex mattress should also provide contour, support, and deep pressure relief. While latex is best as a top or middle mattress layer, it cannot support sleepers by itself. This is why memory foam, high-density foam, and springs are also included in latex designs.
Sleepers who need more bounce than a traditional memory foam design should consider latex. It's also a good choice for people who worry about a product's environmental impact, although these sleepers should opt for natural latex materials. If you want to move away from an innerspring design, but find memory foam too firm, a latex mattress may be right for you.
The Ecosa Mattress
Weighing the above factors, we believe the best latex mattress is the Ecosa. Featuring natural latex and a customisable design, it lets you adjust the firmness level for the perfect feel. You can choose from a medium, medium-firm, or firm setting simply by switching the layers. This is a common feature in hybrid mattresses, but it's rare in an all-foam design. Ecosa also uses memory and high-density foam for pressure relief and support. Another factor that sets the Ecosa apart is the innovative mattress cover. It has a micro-filament inner cover that prevents 99% of dust mites and allergens from entering the foam layer. Also, this fabric is 100% waterproof and breathable. Surrounding this fabric a removable, soft double-knitted polyester cover. Plus, there is a fire-resistant woven silica sock between the outer and inner covers. This contributes to the Ecosa's overall quality and thoughtful latex design.
The Onebed Mattress
While researching, we also found the Onebed is another suitable latex mattress. Also recommended in our firm mattress category, it's made of Dunlop latex, memory foam, and high-density support foam. Although the firmness cannot be adjusted, it's highly-rated by many back and side sleepers. Onebed ships free across Australia and has a generous 125-day trial period.
Best Combination Foam
Our pick — Koala
Almost every mattress we reviewed uses a combination of foam. However, several mattress brands have developed their own types of foam for increased comfort, air flow, cooling, or support. By mixing materials, a mattress can be optimized for different sleeping positions, firmness levels, and body types.
To choose our winner in this category, we looked for a mattress that's best for a variety of sleepers. Testing and feedback helps companies understand what works and what doesn't, so we leaned heavily on customer reviews. A good combination foam mattress uses the right blend of materials for an amazing, balanced feel. You should feel lifted by a firm foam, but experience instant pressure relief from a comfort layer foam. Oftentimes, mattress companies combine a latex and memory foam to achieve this harmony. Others develop their own foam blends to achieve this goal. In both cases, the resulting mattress should bring out the best of each material for a quality sleep.
Combination foam mattresses are ideal for people who are unhappy with innerspring or all-memory foam designs. Spring mattresses cannot provide the same contour as foam, leaving important body parts unsupported. Complete memory foam mattresses are great for some people, but most find them too firm (and outrageously expensive). Mixed foam mattresses are a good middle ground. They work for a range of sleepers and are a better value than high-end memory foam options.
The Koala Mattress
All things considered, our choice for the best combination foam mattress is the Koala. As one of the top-rated designs online, it uses a specialised Kloudcell foam for a "not too firm, not too soft" feel. This material was designed by Koala, and acts like a blend of memory foam and latex. Similar to latex, it's springy and breathable. Like memory foam, it's also great at contouring and cushioning sleepers. The second layer is a high-density eco-foam that provides support and prevents you from sinking too deep. Together, these foams create a mattress that meets the average sleeper's needs. One customer said he's "never felt more comfortable sleeping." While the Koala does take time to break in, the 120-day trial period gives you plenty of time to adjust. Overall, we're not surprised this highly-rated mattress is winning sleepers over one night at a time.
Best Pocket Spring / Hybrid Mattress
Our picks — Eva and Sleep Republic
Hybrid mattresses are great for sleepers who don't fall into any specific category. A combination of traditional spring support and modern foam comfort, hybrids are the best of both mattress designs. They are constructed of coil springs, foam, and other materials, for a feel that you can't get with innerspring or all-foam mattresses. Typically, hybrids feature a top comfort layer of foam or latex. These materials excel at pressure relief and contour. Then, the base layer is made of micro-springs or pocket springs. Like innerspring designs, this layer gives the hybrid mattress bounce and support.
When choosing a hybrid mattress, consider the materials and construction to avoid the downfalls of memory foam or innerspring designs. We looked for quality materials and a stable construction. Weak springs can lose their rebound, and cheap foam can lose its shape. When it comes to construction, a true hybrid only uses springs and foam throughout the mattress. Some semi-hybrids also include a pillow-top layer for extra cushion.
Choosing the right hybrid mattress depends on your specific sleeping needs. You may need more contour, deep compression support, response, bounce, or comfort. Often, sleepers who can't seem to find a comfortable mattress love hybrid designs. Hybrids are also great if you want to swap your innerspring for foam, but are worried about losing bounce or edge support. On the other hand, they are also ideal if you have an all-foam design but are missing the responsiveness of springs.
The Eva Mattress
Everything considered, our team believes the best pocket spring mattress is the Eva. Designed for bounce and body-shaping contour, this mattress is a true hybrid. Customers enjoy sinking into the top layers of latex and gel memory foam. This plush comfort layer ensures there's not too much pressure on the hips, shoulder, neck, or spine. However, the high-density support foam and micro-spring base make the Eva feel firmer than most hybrids. This makes it ideal for back, side, and heavier sleepers—the extra lift will keep the body aligned. It also has sturdier springs around the perimeter, so you're supported when getting out of bed or sitting on the edge. Since the company is just starting out, the Eva is also priced lower than our average mattresses. Yet, the five-star reviews keep rolling in.
The Sleep Republic Mattress
Another quality pocket spring mattress is the Sleep Republic. This hybrid also uses latex, memory foam, dense support foam, and a spring base to give sleepers a solid night's sleep. Keep in mind it's several hundreds dollars more than the Eva, and priced above the average mattress in our index. However, it uses quality materials, is designed by Australians, and ships free across the country.
How we picked and rated
What is the best mattress? To answer this question, we looked at every angle. We first considered the entire Australian mattress market, and then focused in on mattresses you can buy online. From there, we had 12 brands to review, and we gathered data on each mattress. Then, we used many sources to pull information on customer feedback, popularity, trial length, pricing, and warranty information. Each category was rated on a weighted scale of 1-5 and resulted in an overall meta rating for each mattress brand.
Using the ratings to inform our research, we looked deeper into each mattress. Then, we created individual mattress reviews based on customer testimonials, sleeper ratings, and construction information. Lastly, we used our best judgement to match the qualities and characteristics of each mattress to its proper category.
For every design, we also considered where it was made and whether it suits Aussie sleepers. Some had similar ratings, so we relied on customer reviews and good judgement to select a winner for each category. Below, you'll see our results and details about the chosen mattress brands.
No mattress works for everybody
Keep in mind, no one mattress is perfect for everybody. People differ in shape, sleeping position, weight, and firmness preferences. It's impossible to make a "one size fits all" mattress. However, all mattresses fall into certain categories. Most are great for a small group of people, good for some, and just okay for a majority of sleepers. This can make finding the perfect mattress difficult. For one brand we reviewed, a customer said it was "too firm," while another said it was "not firm enough." Since firmness is subjective, it's tricky to interpret customer feedback. Plus, a majority of mattress brands make "medium-firm" models. Even within ratings, there is a diverse range of feel and firmness.
Yet, online mattress brands are making it easier to find the right fit. Most let customers test the mattress during an at-home trial period (many are 100 days). This trial gives your body time to adjust, and helps you make an informed decision. However, it's important to narrow down your options, so you spend more time on a mattress you love. That's why we grouped our mattress choices into popular sleeping categories. We looked at the three common sleeping positions: side, stomach, and back.
Side sleepers usually enjoy a soft but firm mattress that takes pressure off of shoulders and hips. Meanwhile, back sleepers enjoy a firmer mattress that supports the lower back and keeps the neck aligned with the spine. Stomach sleepers like to sink into a mattress and prefer a medium to medium-soft firmness. However, the mattress has to be firm enough to keep the head and neck aligned, without putting pressure on knees and hips. For freestyle sleepers who switch positions all night, a mattress should adjust to movement and adapt to all positions.
All of that explains why we don't choose one overall mattress winner. We go by popular categories, because we know every sleeper needs something different. Your sleeping habits can even change due to stress, sleep apnea, diet, environment, injury, a pillow, and whether or not you sleep with a partner. That's why being able to try a mattress at home is shifting the industry. Choosing the perfect mattress can be tough, but we're here to make it simple and stress-free.